----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Chapter Five

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

WHAT ABOUT HELL & JUDGMENT?

Another word that is grossly misunderstood is in this lifetime will spend eternity in heaven, and those who do not believe in Jesus Christ as Saviour in this lifetime will spend eternity in hell, tormented forever by the flames as the just punishment for their disbelief.

These things, I was taught, are what the Bible say. Is this true?

HELL

In our English translations, three different Greek words are thrown together and translated with the single word

Translated

Translated

Translated

In the Old Testament we find the Hebrew,

Translated

As was the case with

Psa 16:10

THIS IS DAVID SPEAKING! Would David be in hell? Here is an example of an incorrect translation of

HADES IS THE EQUIVALENT OF SHEOL

Act 2:27; Act 2:31 makes a direct reference to the Psalm 16 passage we just looked at. Here we see that

unseen

unseen nor was His flesh acquainted

with decay.

Note that the Concordant Literal translation for

With this inspired passage, we find that

WHAT IS THE PENALTY FOR SIN?

In Gen 2:17 God decreed the penalty for sin:

of the knowledge of good and evil, you are not to be eating from it, for in the

day you eat from it, to die shall you be dying.

In Chapter 3 of Genesis we see the sin of Adam and Eve, and the penalty for sin is executed. They were expelled from the garden, expelled from the presence of God, and prohibited to eat any longer from the tree of life. The process of dying has begun, in accordance with the penalty for sin,

Is the penalty for sin death, or is it an eternity of tormenting in hell?

To be our Saviour, Jesus Christ suffered the penalty for sin on our behalf. Did he suffer death, or did he suffer an eternity in hell in order to pay our debt? The resurrection is proof that every claim of righteousness was fulfilled by Christ.

WHERE DID THE NOTION OF

Our present day notion of

The well known

We have allowed these pagan ideas of

As used in the Word of God,

Many great preachers have proclaimed a message of a fiery, eternal hell. Jonathan Edwards and C. H. Spurgeon are two of the greatest preachers in history, but their eloquence does not make them right. Certainly they preached the truth in many areas, but when it comes to the subject of hell they were clearly basing their beliefs on the incorrect English translations and the incorrect

Let us look to God's Word to understand the destiny of mankind, and not to images created by pagan writers which taint God's character.

DEATH

A close study of Scripture will show us that individuals do not go immediately to heaven (or to hell) immediately upon death. Some will use a few isolated passages of Scripture -- misinterpreted, used out of context, or mistranslated -- to justify the position that the saved go immediately to heaven. This is a study unto itself, and well worth your serious exploration into God's Word.

For now, though, let us look at how

Ecc 12:7 (CVOT)

And the spirit, it returns to the One, Elohim (God), Who gave it.

Consider the example of Jesus. At the point of death He committed His spirit to the Father (Luk 23:46), His soul was in Act 2:27; Act 2:31), and His body was buried in the grave (soil). The only difference in Jesus' case was that God preserved His body from decay (Act 2:31).

In short, death is a return to the original state of existence before God brought the elements (soil and spirit) together to form a living soul. The body, created from the elements of the earth (soil) return to the earth (soil). The spirit which was

The soul, in

Ecc 9:5 (KJV)

Psa 6:5 (NIV)

As we can see, even our common KJV and NIV translations tell us that the dead are not in a conscious state. In some cases death is even equated to sleep (a state of unconsciousness):

Psa 13:3

Dan 12:2

1Th 4:13

them which are asleep.

Death, then, is simply a dissolution or dis-assembly of the body and the spirit, and the soul that was created at the union of the body and the spirit. The soul sleeps in the

Some may protest,

As I write these words I mourn the very recent loss of a dear cousin, barely 50 years old, who will be committed to the grave in the next few days. Knowing he is asleep at this moment instead of in heaven causes me no concern. Either way I will be mourning his loss in this lifetime, and I grieve with his family at the loss they have endured. But I do not mourn as those who have no hope. I praise God and marvel at His grace and His love, knowing that Chuck is now asleep, awaiting the miraculous day of resurrection which is foretold and assured in the Word of God!

INCONSISTENCIES IN THE ENGLISH TRANSLATIONS

Some English translators determine that the evil must go to hell, and they translate sheol as Psa 9:17

hell, and all the nations that forget God

Others are more accurate, translating sheol as

grave, all the nations that forget God.

Consider Job 30:23, where both the KJV and NIV translate sheol as

death, to the place appointed for all

the living.

death, and to the house appointed

for all the living.

Is this not a major inconsistency in the KJV? Job 30:23 says that death is the lot for hell in Psa 9:17. In the Psalm 9 passage the bias of the translators has crept in. They determined in their reasoning that the wicked must be going to hell. But they could not treat the word

A CLOSER LOOK AT

The

The word construction would infer a meaning of

all will go.

Both

GEHENNA

In 2Ch 28:3 and 2Ch 33:6 it is a place where the Jews would sacrifice and burn their children in idolatry. King Josiah, when making his reforms, 2Ki 23:10)

Later the place was used as a garbage dump. In Jesus' day, fires burned in Gehenna to destroy the refuse of Jerusalem.

Much of our problem is that when we hear Jesus talk about the kingdom in the gospels, we think He is talking about heaven. This is what I was always taught. The kingdom and heaven have been confused, just as the translations of

The Old Testament prophets talked about a return of the physical kingdom, like the one in David's day, except with the Lord Himself upon the throne. This is often referred to as the

When Jesus mentions

A complete study of

So

Sanhedrin. Yet whoever may be saying, 'Stupid!' shall be liable to the

Gehenna of fire.Mat 5:22)

for it is expedient for you that one of your members should perish and not

your whole body be cast into Gehenna.Mat 5:29)

Speaking of the futuristic kingdom, the prophet Isaiah fortells:

before me, saith the Lord, so shall your seed and your name remain. And it

shall come to pass, that from one new moon to another, and from one

sabbath to another, shall all flesh come to worship before me, saith the

Lord. And they shall go forth, and look upon the carcases of the men that

have transgressed against me: for their worm shall not die, neither shall

their fire be quenched; and they shall be an abhorring unto all flesh.

(Isa 66:22-24 KJV)

Note that

Those hearing Jesus' words as He spoke would have been quite disturbed about the possibility of being cast into Gehenna. For a Jew to be denied a proper burial would be shameful. To have one's body cast into Gehenna, this refuse dump outside Jerusalem, would be a disgrace.

TARTARUS

The Greek word 2Pe 2:4):

caverns of Tartarus, gives them up to be kept for chastening judging...

This place

Part of the problem, then, is that one Hebrew word and three different Greek words (with three very distinct meanings) have been carelessly combined into a single word

It is interesting to look at our English word

Some common English words, like

LAKE OF FIRE

Besides the various Hebrew and Greek words translated

Rev 19:20

does the signs in its sight, by which he deceives those getting the emblem of the

wild beast, and those worshiping its image. Living, the two were cast into the

lake of fire burning with sulphur.

Rev 20:10 lake

of fire and sulphur, where the wild beast and where the false prophet are also.

And they shall be tormented day and night for the eons of the eons.

In these instances only the wild beast (Adversary/Satan) and the false prophet are cast into the lake of fire, and as we learned in the previous chapter they will be tormented not forever and ever, but for the eons (at least two) of the eons.

Rev 20:13-15

(hades) give up the dead in them. And they were condemned, each in accord with their

acts. And death and the unseen were cast into the lake of fire. This is the second

death-the lake of fire. And if anyone was not found written in the scroll of

life, he was cast into the lake of fire.

Rev 21:7-8

water of life gratuitously. He who is conquering shall be enjoying this allotment,

and I shall be a God to him and he shall be a son to Me. Yet the timid, and

unbelievers, and the abominable, and murderers, and paramours, and enchanters,

and idolaters, and all the false-their part is in the lake of burning with fire and

sulphur, which is the second death.

In these cases referring to humans being cast into the lake of fire,

1. No duration is mentioned, and

2. In both cases the lake of fire is further described as

Based on this description I would say two possibilities exist. We have already seen that tormented for the eons of the eons. No similar mention is made of humans cast into the lake of fire. It may be as simple as their being put to death once again, forfeiting the allotment of

Some may object and say that these creatures being cast into the lake of fire are unworthy and unfit to spend eternity with God in the heavens, even at the end of the ages after having experienced the second death. I would contend that none of us who have confessed Jesus Christ as our Lord and Saviour are ready either. It is only because of the work of Jesus Christ that we are

The other possibility relative to the lake of fire is a conscious period of

1.

2. God's use of fire to purify, instead of to torment, is much more consistent with His character of love.

3. God appeared to Moses in the form of a burning bush (Exodus 3), from which

Moses hid his face.

Could it be that the lake of fire is the very presence of God (as when God appeared to Moses), purifying and refining instead of tormenting?

Consider the following passages:

Jer 9:6-7

to acknowledge me, declares the Lord. Therefore this is what the Lord Almighty

says: See I will refine and test them, for what else can I do because of the sin of

my people?

Mal 3:2-3

he appears? For he will be like a refiner's fire or a launderer's soap. He will sit

as a refiner and purifier of silver; he will purify the Levites and refine them like

gold and silver.

I could never understand how God, who is a God of love, could torment in fire forever those who did not accept Jesus Christ as Saviour in this short lifetime. I can fully understand the lake of fire if its purpose (refinement and purification) is consistent with the love of God, with the ultimate goal of saving all creation at the end of the ages.

I do not question that there is a judgment; surely there is! I do not question that there is a lake of fire! But the Bible tells us that the lake of fire is the second death, and it is not eternal but will one day be abolished. (1 Corinthians 15) If we teach that God will punish men eternally for what they have done during this brief lifetime, it is to charge God with injustice.

THE NATURE OF JUDGMENT AND PUNISHMENT

Dr. David Hartley, a proponent of Universalism who was born in 1705, reasoned:

teaches that the evils of another life will have a like good effect ... The

infinite goodness of God is manifestly an argument in favor of Universal

Salvation.

The Greek

Judgment, damnation, condemnation, accusation, avenge

A passage often used to Mat 25:46,

everlasting punishment: but the righteous

into life eternal.

ethical word at all. It originally meant the pruning of trees to make them grow

better. I think it is true to say that in all Greek secular literature kolasis is

never used of anything but remedial punishment.

Barclay, A Spiritual Autobiography

Michael Phillips quotes from a letter he received from William Barclay as a part of his compiling

punishment. This would enable us to argue that God's punishment is always

for man's cure ... It is the simple fact that in Greek kolasis always means a

remedial punishment.

On the same page, Phillips also quotes A. R. Symonds:

derived from a verb which means to prune. I say its distinctive meaning is this,

in relation to another word, timoria, which signifies vindictive punishment.

In

our Lord, and timoria, a word also used in the New Testament (Heb 10:29):

and the distinctive meanings of these two words are defined by Aristotle

himself. The one word, that used by Christ, denotes, he says, that kind

of punishment which is intended for the improvement of the offender;

while the other denotes that kind of punishment which is intended for

the vindication of law and justice. And even the advocates of endless

torment admit that the word selected by Christ means, according to the

Greek usage, remedial discipline, punishment designed to reform and

improve men, to prune away their defects and sins.

The distinction between

Act 22:5 Paul speaks of his past, when he led the believers to Jerusalem

to be punished.

Act 26:11 Paul again speaks of his persecution and punishment

the believers.

Heb 10:29 Speaks of the punishmentdeserved by

one who

John Wesley Hanson writes in

the improvement of his children.

In Job 5:17-18 we read:

the chastening of the Almighty. For he maketh sore, and bindeth up; he

woundeth, and his hands make whole.

The argument was introduced by Augustine that if th century A.D. that theologians began for the first time to introduce the sense of endlessness, rather than eonian (or age-abiding) which had been the interpretation prior to that time.

It seems, then, that the new meanings for the words

For example, Mat 25:46 reads:

eternal.

This verse is translated in the CLNT:

life eonian.

Rotherham's Emphasized Bible translates this passage:

age-abiding life.

God has always stressed the importance of forgiveness:

indeed repent, forgive him. And if he should ever be sinning against you

seven times a day, and if he should ever be turning about seven times a

day to you, saying, 'I am repenting,' you shall be forgiving him.

(Luk 17:3-4)

brother be sinning against me and I shall be pardoning him? Till seven

times?' Jesus is saying to him, 'I am not saying to you Till seven times,

but Till seventy times and seven.'Mat 18:21-22)

Of the lost ones, Jesus said:

leaving the ninety-nine in the wilderness and is going after the lost one,

till he may be finding it?Luk 15:3-4)

How can one be chastised and corrected if the punishment lasts forever? How can God, who places such emphasis on forgiveness, come to the point where He refuses to forgive? How can God, who places importance on the one lost sheep, be satisfied if all the sheep are not securely in the fold when all is said and done?

Does it not make better sense that the purpose of judgment is for correction, in preparation for a future day when every knee shall bow before Him? Is this not more consistent with God's character of love and forgiveness?

Could God really be filled with love and power and wisdom, and yet be unable or unwilling to find a way to bring the necessary correction to every one of His creation, in order that every knee bows before Him?

Consider the facts.

Man was created through no act of his own, but only through the will of God.

Man, in the Garden of Eden, was tempted by evil, and God knew beforehand of man's being predisposed to evil.

In his short lifetime, man is continually exposed to temptation.

But if man does not respond by accepting Jesus Christ as his Saviour in this short

lifetime, he is consigned to an eternal torment in hell.

Is this logical? Does it not place a great emphasis on the ability of man to see through his depravity, and to overcome the temptation all around him, to make a

If an earthly ruler condemned even the vilest criminal to be kept alive just to be tortured forever, we would shudder at his cruelty. But we have inherited the current orthodox teachings about God that calmly attribute such activities to Him, while also teaching that He is a God of love.

I have come to see that the Bible does not teach this at all. Man has intervened and has placed his philosophies and pagan ideas within the Word of God. The modern English translations now perpetuate these man-made ideas, primarily because of a few words mis-translated and misinterpreted. We see a God of love, but a God who is also very harsh. Some say this is necessary because of God's holiness and justice, but is God not able to use His love and power to bring about justice without losing a single sheep from the fold?

SUMMARY

The penalty for sin is death.

Christ paid the penalty for sin on our behalf.

If the penalty for sin had been eternal torment, Christ would have had to pay that penalty.

The resurrection shows us that the penalty could not have been eternal torment, or

Christ would still be paying that price on our behalf.

If one dies without faith in Christ, he would be subject to the penalty for sin ... death.

(This is the second death ... the lake of fire.)

But because Christ overcame death, at the consummation (at the end of the ages)

death will be abolished, and those within the lake of fire (second death) will be

reconciled with God, who becomes All in all. (1 Corinthians 15)

STUDY FOR YOURSELF

I am not asking you to believe these things based on my opinions. I have presented some Biblical references in support of my arguments, but encourage you to study for yourself. In light of what I have told you, look at all of the occurrences of these key Hebrew and Greek words. Don't trust the modern English translators who have built their own biases into the translation. Throw off your previously biased images of

SHEOL (65 occurrences) - KJV translation precedes each group of references

Grave: Gen 37:35; Gen 42:38; Gen 44:29; Gen 44:31; 1Sa 2:6; 1Ki 2:6; 1Ki 2:9; Job 7:9; Job 14:13; Job 17:13; Job 21:13; Job 24:19; Psa 6:5; Psa 30:3; Psa 31:17; Psa 49:14-15; Psa 88:3; Psa 89:48; Psa 141:7; Pro 1:12; Pro 30:16; Ecc 9:10; Son 8:6; Isa 14:11; Isa 38:10; Isa 38:18; Eze 31:15; Hos 13:14.

Hell: Deu 32:22; 2Sa 22:6; Job 11:8; Job 26:6; Psa 9:17; Psa 16:10; Psa 18:5; Psa 55:15; Psa 86:13; Psa 116:3; Psa 139:8; Pro 5:5; Pro 7:27; Pro 9:18; Pro 15:11; Pro 15:24; Pro 23:14; Pro 27:20; Isa 5:14; Isa 14:9; Isa 14:15; Isa 28:15; Isa 28:18; Isa 57:9; Eze 31:16-17; Eze 32:21; Eze 32:27; Amo 9:2; Jon 2:2; Hab 2:5

The Pit: Num 16:30; Num 16:33; Job 17:16

HADES (11 occurrences)

Hell: Mat 11:23; Mat 16:18; Luk 10:15; Luk 16:23; Act 2:27; Act 2:31; Rev 1:18; Rev 6:8; Rev 20:13-14.

Grave: 1Co 15:55

GEHENNA (12 occurrences)

Hell: Mat 5:22; Mat 5:29-30; Mat 10:28; Mat 18:9; Mat 23:15; Mat 23:33; Mar 9:43; Mar 9:45; Mar 9:47; Luk 12:5; Jam 3:6

TARTARUS (1 occurrence)

Hell: 2Pe 2:4

LAKE OF FIRE (5 occurrences)

For wild beast, false prophet Satan: Rev 19:20; Rev 20:10

For irreverant mankind: Rev 20:14-15; Rev 21:8